Starter for Ten
A musical centring around the academic’s genius quiz University Challenge may seem an odd concept for a show, however this brand-new British musical certainly has all the right answers! Based on the novel by David Nicholls and the HBO/Playtone film, Starter for Ten is the perfect show to bring joy and happiness onto the stage, with well rounded characters, lots of humour and some very catchy songs courtesy of Hatty Carman and Tom Rasmussen.
Set in the 1980’s, Brian (Adam Bregman) has an ambition to star on University Challenge, a show loved and watched by him and his Dad throughout his childhood. After securing a place at Bristol University, Brian is able to cement his place on the team, however, will he be able to win, or fail at the final hurdle? The book and lyrics by Emma Hall and Charlie Parham take us on a journey of self-discovery, love triangles and humour as we meet a multitude of interesting, and sometimes slightly crazy characters, all of whom provide moments of brilliance within the story. Bregman impressed with fantastic vocals and carried the story along well. Mel Giedroyc as Brian’s Mum / Julia Bland was every inch the comic genius with her Victoria Wood-esque stage presence and natural talent. Every moment she appeared on stage left a smile on your face.
Throughout the story we see Bamber Gascoigne, the original presenter of University Challenge who appears to Brian as somewhat as a vision at various points, and what a vision he was. Stephen Ashfield perfectly portrayed Gascoigne with a delightfully camp edge, which again delivered many laughs throughout. Love interest of Brian, Alice was played by Imogen Craig with such class. In her professional debut, Craig is certainly one to watch in the future as her performance was polished and full of charm. Asha Parker-Wallace plays Brians second love interest, Rebecca and was vocally exceptional especially during the closing song of the first act ‘Heroes’.
Special mentions must also go to Will Jennings as Patrick, the head of the Bristol University Challenge team who was that archetypal academic nerd. Jennings was another reason for more smiling throughout with his comedic talent. Miracle Chance as Lucy and Christian Maynard as Spencer were also well cast, offering up more star quality to this incredible stage full of talent.
The costuming by Lee Newby was firmly grounded in the 1980’s, with big hair, shoulder pads and denim looks that transported me back to that golden age, and my own memories of growing up in this incredible decade. The set, also by Newby was familiar to any fan of University Challenge with the teams of four sat next to their team mascot and their surnames lit up for all to see. These touches and nods to the original programme were a delight to see.
This story was more than just an homage to University Challenge though, it explored loss, love and everything in between. There were many moments of tenderness, amidst the humour which made this show a complete 5-star offering. Whatever the question is, the answer is go and support new British musical theatre, as you may be pleasantly surprised with the exceptional talent we have in this country, a fact echoed by the packed auditorium, which was a joy to see.
This show was reviewed on the 25th October 2025 at Birmingham REP where it runs until the 1st November 2025. Tickets available here: Starter for Ten | Birmingham Rep
Review written by Emma Rowley
AD/Gifted
Photo credit: Pamela Raith
Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show.