Heathers The Musical
There is something undeniably electric about Heathers the Musical. Even after multiple West End runs and national tours, this dark, deliciously wicked 1980s high school satire continues to pack a serious punch. This summer, it finds a temporary home in Central London’s newest pop-up space, The Arts at Marble Arch (a temporary venue to replace the Arts Theatre off Leicester Square whilst it’s being refurbished) prior to embarking on a UK tour.
While the production itself is a triumph of stellar performances, infectious music, and sharp direction, the limitations of the brand-new venue hold it back from a perfect 5-star score.
Andy Fickman’s direction remains as slick and fast-paced as ever, capturing the perfect balance of cartoonish high-school comedy and genuine, pitch-black psychological drama while the new cast without exception earn their place on the stage. Gerardine Sacdalan (Veronica Sawyer) is fresh from her success in & Juliet, she brings a gorgeous, soulful vocal power and a brilliantly grounded, empathetic warmth to Veronica. Her transition from a desperate-to-please misfit to a shell-shocked survivor is beautifully mapped whilst Louis Hearsey (J.D.) plays the unhinged trench-coat-wearing rebel with a magnetic, simmering danger. The sizzling chemistry between him and Sacdalan is palpable, making the tragic spiral of their relationship feel both inevitable and heartbreaking.
The musical's score remains an absolute earworm. Backed by a remarkably tight band, the vocals soar in numbers like "Candy Store" and the emotional peak "Dead Girl Walking". Every harmony is crisp, and the sound design within the auditorium does a brilliant job of amplifying the heavy-hitting, rock-synth energy of the 1980s. The choreography by Gary Lloyd is executed with frantic, flawless precision by an incredibly high-energy ensemble.
While The Arts at Marble Arch is an admirable, highly ambitious temporary space—cleverly constructed with tiered grandstand seating that offers fantastic views from (almost) every angle—its physical limitations are hard to ignore.
As a temporary structure situated right on one of London's busiest traffic islands, the noise bleed from outside is a persistent issue. During the show’s quieter, more intimate moments, the ambient rumble of the Marble Arch traffic, occasional honking horns, and passing sirens pierce right through the walls. It’s a frustrating distraction that repeatedly threatens to pull you out of Westerberg High and dump you right back onto the corner of Oxford Street. It seems that, in an attempt to drown out the external noise, the music is played at times a little uncomfortably loud. It’s a huge shame that at times it’s difficult to remain completely focussed on the wonderful performances when the external noises are so persistent.
Heathers itself is in top-tier form. The cast is world-class, the songs are as addictive as ever, and the production values are outstanding.
If you can look (or rather, hear) past the occasional rumble of a London double-decker bus outside, this is still an absolute must-see this summer. This teen angst show has a body count!
This show was reviewed on the 13th July 2026 at The Arts at Marble Arch, London where it runs until the 22nd August 2026. Tickets available here: London - Heathers The Musical
Full tour details here: About - Heathers The Musical
Review written by Mike Stocks
AD/Gifted
Photo credit : Pamela Raith
Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show